[Az-Geocaching] Best battery

Thu Nov 8 13:32:29 MST 2007

More info on batteries:

Battery Technology
Currently the Palm Computing and TRGpro PDA's have the option to
recharge batteries in situ, but for other PDAs knowing which battery
is right for your PDA can save a lot of frustration and wasted
expense.

Battery classes:

Batteries are available either as disposable or rechargeable as
follows: Non-Rechargeable, Rechargeable, Disposable, NiCad, Alkaline,
NiMH, Lithium, Lithium Ion & Renewable Alkaline

Battery metrics:

There are two relevant measurements, voltage and milliamp hours (mAh).
Voltage is the power a battery can deliver. mAh is the time that power
can be delivered. That means if you have two 1.5 Volt batteries, and
one is rated at 2000 mAh and the other is rated at 2500 mAh, the 2500
mAh battery lasts longer. That doesn't mean the higher capacity cell
performs better. Batteries respond to loads differently. Memory cards
and modems are massive loads to batteries. You may experience low
voltage conditions with brand new alkaline batteries because they do
not respond to power surges as well as Lithium, Nicad, and NiMH
batteries. What works on one machine, may not work on another.

Milliampere Hours (mAh):

Most HPCs run at about 200 mAh. HPCs are 3v devices, so two AA
batteries in series equal 3 Volts. Divide the mAh of the batteries
(2600 for two AA alkalines) and you can figure the run time. When you
add components like a PCMCIA card, add that mAh rating and usage time
to the mix. There is a caveat for this formula for Alkalines. They are
rated to their cutoff point, but the HPC stops working long before
that.

Voltage:

Voltage is like horsepower in a motor. Consider a 4-cylinder 120 HP
car and a 250 HP truck pulling a heavy boat and trailer. While both do
reasonably well on a flat surface, the small car labours when it comes
to a hill. Both vehicles must exert the same force to pull the trailer
up the hill at the same speed. But one has a better capacity for doing
so. The same applies for batteries. A 5v source is better able to
deliver power to PCMCIA cards because the cards require 5v. A 3v
source must first convert amps into a higher voltage. It works harder
and burns out sooner under these conditions.

Alkaline Batteries:

Alkaline batteries are predictable. Brand new batteries deliver 1.5
Volts at 2600 mAh. While they have a long shelf life (90% after five
years), they begin degrading when you start using them. So while they
start at 1.5v, this drops through usage. Since the degradation rate is
constant and known, you can measure the voltage and determine how much
life is left in the batteries. This is how power management software
operates. Alkaline batteries have cut off voltages around 0.9v. Your
HPC won't work with voltage that low. So, you are going to get less
than the rated capacity out of alkaline batteries. How low can the
voltage be? Somewhere around 1.1v. On a positive note, you can take
the "dead" batteries from your HPC and still use them in something
that doesn't demand so much power. The batteries from different
manufacturers are different and they respond to surges differently. If
your brand new alkalines give you a power warning when you connect to
a modem or memory board, they probably don't perform well under heavy
loads. Before you curse your HPC, try different batteries. This is
especially true of some renewables which are rated at only 1.2v.

Rechargeable Alkaline Manganese (RAM) Batteries:

High power and longer lasting batteries continue to be in demand even
more so today. Battery applications are continually expanding as
consumers are constantly looking for portable new solutions to fit
their fast pace of life. Consumers, however, are also now demanding
batteries that are environmentally friendly, convenient and easy to
use, and most of all economical.
Developed by some of the same individuals who founded the original
Alkaline (disposable) battery, Rechargeable Alkaline Manganese(RAM)
batteries offer the consumer the high alkaline power they are used to,
but much more economically. It is quite clearly the best of both
worlds…. All the features and benefits of Alkaline batteries, with the
added benefit of being rechargeable.
While RAM batteries compete with existing rechargeable products
(Nickel Cadmium), as well as with disposable alkaline batteries, they
should not be confused with conventional "old-fashioned"
rechargeables. RAM batteries have none of the limitations of the
existing rechargeable products.
RAM batteries offer a long shelf life (typically 5 years) and give,
based on AA batery size, a full 1.5 Volt at 2000mAh. RAM batteries are
also environmentally friendly as the contain 0% cadmium and also 0%
mercury.
RAM batteries do not suffer from the "memory effect", on the contrary
the earlier the recharge the better allowing RAM batteries to be
recharged up to 250+ times.

Lithium:

Eveready manufactures Lithium batteries. These batteries have a long
shelf life (90% at 10 years). Lithium batteries maintain a constant
voltage over the life of the battery and performs well under heavy
loads. Like alkalines, they have a high capacity (2600 mAh), and their
starting voltage is 1.5v. Lithium battery voltage does not degrade
until the battery is nearly discharged, so you get full advantage of
the battery's rated capacity. When these batteries die, they die
quickly. Because their degradation characteristics are not known,
Power Management software does not work well with these batteries. It
tells you if the batteries are still good. By the time it tells you
they are weak, you are close to going on backup. Depending on your
HPC, this should not be a problem. At most, you may lose active data,
but you should not lose data already stored on the HPC.

NiCads:

NiCads (Nickel Cadmium) are the most used rechargeable batteries
today. They have many good features, and last a long time. You can buy
NiCads and a charger off-the-shelf and use them instead of AAs. MiCads
are considerably more expensive than Lithium or Alkalines. NiCads
perform the same way as Lithium batteries but they don't die as
quickly. Their starting voltage is 1.25v and they hold their charge
for the life of the battery. They are very good at responding to power
surges, which means they provide reliable power for many applications.
There are various brands available. NiCads have several disadvantages.
The capacity is much less than Lithium and alkalines, and they
dissipate just sitting on the shelf - 10% in the first 24 hours. It's
use it or lose it with NiCads. Also, to get full potential from the
batteries you have to let them drain completely. They are infamous for
their "memory" effect-crystals forming on the cell plates. As the
crystals build up, the battery's maximum charge potential degrades.
(Fully discharging the batteries breaks down the crystals.) Finally,
if you are environmentally conscious, NiCads contain heavy metal
cadmium, which is a targeted environmental pollutant.

NiMH:

The next most popular rechargeable battery is Nickel Metal Hydride
(NiMH). Designers find NiMH attractive because its energy density is
considerably greater than NiCad. That means the NiMH battery holds
100% or more charge over a NiCad that is the same size. Like NiCads,
NiMH batteries hold their charge for most of their rated capacity and
then drop off very quickly. NiMH batteries do not respond to high
power draws as well as NiCads. The self-discharge rate of NiMH is
about 1.5 times that of NiCads, the cycle life of recharges is smaller
(about 500), and they generate more heat during recharging. Despite
these drawbacks, NiMH will continue to gain market share. People using
the batteries are not concerned with shelf life (although
self-discharge is crucial in charging). They are concerned about
capacity and getting power. Unlike NiCads and their memory effect,
NiMH batteries perform better when charged frequently. Finally, they
contain no heavy metals.

Lithium Ion:

After a tough (explosive) start in the commercial market, Lithium Ion
is gaining popularity. Lithium Ion combines the best of NiCad and
NiMH. It has a low self-discharge rate, it is environmentally safe,
has no memory, and holds a high number of recharge cycles. In
addition, it responds well to high current draw. Its composition makes
it the lightest of all the batteries, and it has the greatest energy
density. Since its composition is unstable, Lithium Ion is difficult
to work with. The batteries require circuitry to prevent thermal
runaway during charging. The circuitry also limits the maximum
discharge. This makes Lithium Ion the most expensive of all the
batteries for HPCs.

Chargers:

Chargers are a lot more complex than most people realize. First, the
charger must provide the proper current for optimal charging. Second,
the charger must limit voltage to avoid overcharging. Third, the
charger must balance the charging rate against the heat generated
during charging. Too much heat (thermal runaway) or gas (venting) in a
battery is catastrophic. Last, the charger must match the battery's
self-discharge at full charge. This is because NiCads and NiMH
batteries lose 10-15% of their charge within 24 hours of full charge.
To obtain a full charge, the charger must offset that discharge.
Because battery chemistry changes from battery to battery, it is very
important that the charger is built for the battery's particular
characteristics. This is the reason you have chargers for all your
rechargeable batteries - phone, computer, HPC, etc. You risk damage or
even an explosion, by using chargers not designed for the battery.

Battery drainers:

PCMCIA modems are notorious for killing HPC batteries. That's because
they require up to 5.8v for operation with a 5.2v minimum. Why?
Telephone companies use 3-6v on the standard phone to generate the
analog phone signal. To get lower power requirements in PC Card modems
would require telephone companies worldwide to lower their power
requirements. Don't hold your breath for that to happen. And by the
way: even software modems must still power that phone signal. Powering
wireless devices is a massive drain on batteries. The modem
requirements aside, dialing a cellular phone requires 4.8v or more.
Don't expect your HPC's batteries to power a wireless modem. Then
there is color. All CE 1.0 units had grayscale screens. HP was the
first on the market with a colour unit, Sharp followed, and now most
of the manufacturers have followed suit. As a rule of thumb, running
colour is like running your unit with the backlight constantly on. For
this reason, most colour devices use NiMH or Li-Ion batteries instead
of alkalines.

On Nov 8, 2007 1:11 PM, ShadowAce <shadowace.az at gmail.com> wrote:
> Maybe this could be helpful?
>
> http://www.users.on.net/~mhains/
>
> Compares some of the features
>
>
>
> On Nov 8, 2007 7:11 AM, Bob & Linda Smith < Lrsmith at cableone.net> wrote:
> > It has been a while since we had this conversation and I find most of my
> > NiMh batteries no longer hold a charge for very long.  Has anyone tried
> > these batteries yet:  RAM (Rechargeable Alkaline Manganese)  I read a
> > note about them on the Garmin listserv last August and wanted to try
> > them at that time but could not speak German where the link took me.
> > I'm shopping for the best AA battery for my GPS and Camera's -- your
> > thoughts???
> >
> > Bob Smith, Prescott, AZ  Team Petite Elite
> > Prescott, AZ
> >
> > ____________________________________________________________
> > Az-Geocaching mailing list listserv at azgeocaching.com
> > To edit your setting, subscribe or unsubscribe visit:
> > http://listserv.azgeocaching.com/mailman/listinfo/az-geocaching
> >
> > Arizona's Geocaching Resource
> > http://www.azgeocaching.com
> >
>
>
> ____________________________________________________________
> Az-Geocaching mailing list listserv at azgeocaching.com
> To edit your setting, subscribe or unsubscribe visit:
> http://listserv.azgeocaching.com/mailman/listinfo/az-geocaching
>
> Arizona's Geocaching Resource
> http://www.azgeocaching.com
>
>